Tag Archives: Online Commenting

No More Anonymous Comments. Long Live Anonymous Comments!

Mathew Ingram of GigaOm takes issue with the Huffington Post which starting next month will no longer allow anonymous comments.

Do we encourage trolls and offensive behavior when we allow people to contribute anonymously? Perhaps. But free speech comes with a price, and I think we lose something significant when we start requiring people to verify their identities before we listen to what they have to say. If that’s what is required for a “grown-up internet” then I would like to stick with the one we have.

Advertisements
Tagged , , , , , , , , , ,

Making Comments Smarter: The Verge And The Huffington Post

PandoDaily

PandoDaily

Internet forums and comment sections are the netherworld of the Web. Thankfully, many media companies are revamping the way they do comments. Writing at PandoDaily, Hamish McKenzie outlines the shortcomings of online discussion and presents the commenting innovations of The Verge, The Huffington Post and others.

Two advancements that McKenzie explains are notable.

1) Curated forums that serve as miniature communities for readers and the author. This is currently being implemented at all of Gawker’s sites (Gawker, Jezebel, Gizmodo) as well as ReadWrite and The Verge.

2) Up-voting and internal organization of comments. Similar to Reddit and Quora, The Huffington Post is deploying a platform enabling favorable comments to rise to the top, achieving prominence. This helps readers sort through the hundreds of crap comments and draws their attention to what the crowd or the gods have deemed important.

Tagged , , , , , , , ,
Advertisements